Skip to guide content

Battle Arena guide

Winner Stays Strategy

Plan an opening run and later entrants while accounting for replacement order, carried injury, fatigue and one progression count per entrant.

Reviewed Revision 1
On this page

Beginner summary

Winner Stays begins with each team's first Uppie. The winner of a duel stays in combat, carrying its remaining health. Only the defeated fighter is replaced, using the next position in its own lineup. A team wins by defeating all five opposing fighters.

Current rules add temporary workload fatigue before another duel. A strong opener can defeat several opponents, but injury, fatigue and the next matchup can end its run. Later positions provide fresh entrants rather than guaranteed matching pairs.

Detailed explanation

Following replacement order

A survivor is the fighter that won the previous duel and remains alive. An entrant is a fighter coming into combat. A sweep is one fighter defeating all five opponents in the same team battle.

Both teams start at position 1. If your opener beats the opposing opener, it next faces opposing position 2 while your own second fighter waits. If opposing position 2 then wins, it stays and your position 2 enters. Each side advances only when its current fighter is defeated.

You choose the lineup order before combat; you do not select a replacement mid-duel or swap a surviving fighter out. The battle ends immediately when one squad has lost all five fighters. A normally completed battle contains five to nine duels. The winning team has five duel wins; the losing team can have zero to four.

Survivor condition and fresh entrants

The survivor carries health left after the duel. Before another opponent, current workload fatigue can reduce that health further and accumulate a temporary reduction in effective Attack. Longer exchanges create more workload, with level affecting the treatment. Fatigue cannot knock out the survivor by itself, and no next-duel fatigue is applied after the battle-ending win.

A fresh entrant starts with its own full health, including applicable Bond, and no temporary fatigue. Permanent ratings do not change. Injury and fatigue reset for a separate team battle, including another battle in a series. See Survivor Health and Workload Fatigue for the complete reset table.

Choosing an opener

The opener is guaranteed to enter a normally completed Winner Stays battle. It has the first opportunity to build a run, but also must face whatever opening matchup occurs. Consider Type, level, Attack, Defence, Speed, Ability and Bond together.

Spending more squad budget on the opener can leave weaker replacements. An IPU costs 12 points and is still subject to current fatigue; being an IPU does not guarantee a sweep. A modest opener with a useful pairing may contribute, but a favourable Type alone does not determine the result.

Choosing later entrants

Later fighters may face an injured survivor rather than the opponent in the same lineup position. They may also never enter. Think about useful responses to the opponents that could defeat earlier teammates, while preserving legal costs and coverage against other possibilities.

If the opponent's order or traits are unknown, this is contingency planning, not a known sequence. A later fresh fighter can face a stronger survivor; fresh health is an advantage to consider rather than proof of victory.

Type and ability interactions

Every new opponent creates a new matchup. A survivor's natural Type may be favourable in one duel and unfavourable in the next. Adapt softens its holder's outgoing disadvantage; Resilience can reduce incoming hits at a natural disadvantage. Specialist neutralises outgoing disadvantage against one fixed target, not both weaknesses, and does not remove the opponent's favourable reply. Its target does not change between duels and the current card does not identify that individual target.

Temporary ability state resets for each new duel. Opening Gambit can apply to another first attack; Last Stand has a fresh first-lethal-hit chance. Counterpunch and Comeback do not carry a prepared attack from the previous opponent. Low carried health may meet Finisher's opposing-health condition, but simply arriving hurt does not prepare Comeback. Resetting abilities does not restore HP or erase fatigue.

Level and rating conditions also use the actual new opponent. Giant Killer needs both fighters normal and an opponent at least three levels higher. Underdog requires any higher-level opponent and a successful chance check. Pressure requires Rare or Ultra Rare opposing Defence; Fortify requires Rare or Ultra Rare opposing Attack. Fatigue does not relabel those permanent rating bands. See the approved references instead of assuming an ability stays eligible throughout a run.

Duels, appearances and progression

In eligible recorded combat, each actual Winner Stays entrant gains one Discovery and one Bond participation per team battle, even if it fights several duels. Losing still counts; unused reserves gain neither. Practice, development/test battles, unfought outcomes and rewatching do not add qualifying participation.

Supported individual career records count actual duels separately from battles entered and squad appearances. One opener can have one appearance, one battle fought, five duel wins and five KOs from a sweep, while gaining only one progression count. Legacy aggregate career counters can instead record the team outcome for all five squad members, including reserves; those are not individual duel wins.

Detailed career statistics currently have an unresolved loading issue. Missing or partial records are not proof of zero fights, and current ownership does not automatically expose another owner's private battle history.

Applicable rules and availability

This describes current locally implemented Winner Stays v2. Deployed and operational availability remain unverified. Five different eligible fighters and the chosen ruleset remain mandatory. Normal Open challenges require 21–26 squad points, normal levels cost their level, and an IPU costs 12. Exact-level and IPU-only presets have their own restrictions and totals; see Building a Squad.

Important exceptions

Positions 1–3 are not all guaranteed to fight in Winner Stays; only the opener has that guarantee in normal completed combat. A successful opener can leave all four teammates unused. A forfeit, cancellation or bye is not a sweep and does not create fought duels.

Initiative is decided for every new duel. A survivor is not guaranteed the next first attack. Bond supplies applicable full health at entry, not repeated healing. Rewatching the battle does not recalculate outcomes, add workload or grant extra progression.

Practical examples

A changing pair

Suppose A1 beats B1, then loses to B2. B2 next faces A2; B3 still waits. If A2 wins, it faces B3. The second duel was A1 versus B2, so this was not Classic's matching-position sequence.

A single-fighter sweep

Imagine A1 defeats B1 through B5. Team A wins 5–0. A1 fought five duels; A2–A5 never entered. In qualifying combat, A1 gains one Discovery and one Bond count. Each defeated B fighter also gains one of each because each entered. A's unused reserves gain none.

A planned response is only a possibility

Your Pirate opener might lose to an Alien survivor. Putting a Robot next gives a favourable natural Type against that Alien. However, the Alien may not be the opponent that survives, and level, health, attributes and abilities still matter. The order prepares an option, not a guaranteed reversal.

The budget and participation tradeoff

An IPU followed by Levels 5, 4, 3 and 2 costs 26 points. Levels 8, 6, 5, 4 and 3 also cost 26. Both fit normal Open's point range if otherwise eligible. The IPU lineup concentrates more points in one fighter; the other distributes them differently. A sweep can win quickly while leaving four teammates without progression, whereas later entrants only progress if they actually fight.

A run ends but its contribution remains

An opener wins two duels and loses the third. Its record can include two wins, two KOs and one loss even if its team later loses the battle. It still gains only one qualifying Discovery and Bond count. The team result does not erase the duels it won.

Strategic considerations

Choose an opener for the expected first pairing and the possibility of continued combat. Then choose later positions for plausible surviving threats. Consider the cost of a long exchange as well as the possibility of winning it; fatigue means the survivor's next duel is not a fresh rematch.

Balance team victory, depth and progression deliberately. Placing a developing fighter late protects your opening plan but risks no participation. Placing it first ensures entry in normal completed combat while potentially exposing the rest of the lineup to an opposing run. Neither choice is universally correct.

Common questions

Table 47: Question, Answer
QuestionAnswer
Does the winner heal before the next opponent?No. Remaining health carries, and current fatigue can reduce it further.
Can I choose a different replacement during combat?No. The next position enters automatically after a defeat.
Is first to three enough?No. Winner Stays requires defeating all five opponents.
Can one fighter win the whole battle?Yes, a five-opponent sweep is possible, not guaranteed.
Do five duel wins give five Discovery counts?No. One actual entrant receives one count per qualifying team battle.
Will position 3 always fight?No. Later teammates can remain unused behind a successful survivor.
Does a new duel reset everything?No. Temporary ability state resets, but survivor health and fatigue carry.

Historical versions

Winner Stays v1 carried remaining health without current v2 workload fatigue. Winner Stays v2 adds temporary health and effective-Attack fatigue before another duel. Both replace the defeated fighter in lineup order. Use the recorded version for a replay; do not apply v2 effects retroactively.

Legacy team-outcome career counters and current individual duel statistics answer different questions. Newer records or features do not imply every historical battle was backfilled. The approved progression guide explains these distinctions in more detail.

Review metadata

Revision 1, approved by the project owner on 2026-10-16 (Australia/Sydney) for the local Game Guide. Deployed and operational availability have not been verified.

Back to top ↑